Neutrogena Ultra Sheer vs Indie Lee Mineral Sunscreen - which works better under makeup?

Makeup lovers constantly ask which SPF disappears under foundation. Our head-to-head of Neutrogena Ultra Sheer vs Indie Lee Mineral Sunscreen answers that, focusing on finish, wear-time and price.

Why the right sunscreen makes or breaks your makeup day

The quest for the perfect sunscreen-makeup combination has reached a critical point. According to recent surveys, 99% of healthcare providers believe that if sunscreen offered better application and aesthetic experiences, patients would use their sunscreen more often. This statistic underscores a fundamental truth: texture and finish determine whether your SPF becomes a seamless base or a makeup disaster.

Growing consumer awareness of environmental impacts has shifted preferences toward mineral-based options. The challenge? Finding formulas that provide protection without compromising your carefully crafted makeup look. Advancements in formulation technology have addressed previous drawbacks like white cast and thick textures, making modern mineral sunscreens more makeup-friendly than ever.

The difference between a sunscreen that pills under foundation versus one that creates a smooth canvas can mean the difference between confident all-day wear and midday touch-up disasters. Experience broad-spectrum SPF protection with formulas designed to work harmoniously with makeup has become the new standard.

Specs snapshot: filters, finish & SPF levels

When comparing sunscreens for makeup compatibility, understanding the technical specifications provides crucial insight into performance. Here's how these two contenders stack up:

Formulated with titanium dioxide, zinc oxide and vitamin E, the Purescreen+ mineral sunscreen is hypoallergenic, vegan, non-comedogenic and fragrance-free, specifically designed to dry quickly and work under makeup.

The 20% uncoated Zinc Oxide in Indie Lee provides broad spectrum SPF 30 protection, while zinc oxide tends to have broader-spectrum coverage than titanium dioxide alone. However, the combination of both minerals in the Ultra Sheer formula provides the most comprehensive protection.

Both products represent the shift toward reef-safe formulations that modern consumers demand, avoiding harmful chemicals while maintaining effective sun protection.

Real-skin test: Neutrogena Ultra Sheer under makeup

This SPF 70 formula delivers impressive real-world performance metrics. With 90% of users agreeing it spreads easily and 85% agreeing it dries quickly, the product promises an invisible finish and up to eight hours of hydration.

Non-comedogenic mineral sunscreen that won't clog pores, this formula works exceptionally well under makeup. The lightweight consistency sets it apart from traditional mineral products, providing SPF 70 protection suitable for high sun exposure or hyperpigmentation concerns.

Practical application reveals specific strengths: "Neutrogena Ultra Sheer Sunscreen is lightweight, not greasy, and honestly, it's so sheer you barely notice it's there." The formula works particularly well for oily and combination skin types due to its mattifying properties.

However, users should note that water resistance extends to 80 minutes, requiring reapplication during extended wear or physical activity.

Strengths & gaps of Indie Lee Mineral Sunscreen

Indie Lee's mineral sunscreen brings a different approach to sun protection. Squalene, Shea Butter and Aloe provide rich moisture to keep skin hydrated all day long, making it likely good for dry skin types.

The brand's commitment extends beyond skincare. Formulating products without more than 1,300 banned ingredients, Indie Lee maintains 100% cruelty-free certification through the Leaping Bunny program.

Yet practical testing reveals limitations. The consistency is definitely heavy and hard to spread on the skin. Users report significant white cast even after attempting to blend for extended periods, which poses challenges for makeup application.

Finish, cast & pilling: side-by-side wear tests

The true test of any sunscreen comes during actual makeup application. Independent testing reveals stark differences between these formulas in real-world conditions.

Neutrogena Ultra Sheer demonstrates superior performance with a significant portion of users praising its lightweight consistency that doesn't feel like traditional mineral products. The quick-drying formula minimizes the window for pilling, crucial for smooth foundation application.

"Ultra Sheer Mineral Face Liquid Sunscreen stands out for its lightweight, high-SPF mineral protection and invisible finish, which I hope will encourage more people to wear sunscreen daily."

Conversely, Indie Lee's heavier texture creates application challenges. Observations show significant white cast persisting even after blending attempts. This visible residue interferes with makeup color matching and can alter foundation shade.

The formulation differences become apparent during extended wear. "Avoid Oxybenzone at all costs" - thankfully, both products steer clear of this problematic ingredient. However, the dual-mineral approach provides better application aesthetics according to 99% of healthcare providers surveyed.

Ingredient safety & environmental stance

Both sunscreens prioritize clean formulations, but their approaches differ significantly. Oxybenzone penetrates skin easily and causes hormone disruption - neither product contains this harmful chemical.

Indie Lee's commitment to sustainability extends to ocean protection with reef-safe formulations that don't harm marine life. Meanwhile, gentle sunscreen face liquid from the competing brand is formulated free from fragrance, oxybenzone, parabens, and phthalates.

The product can be considered reef safe because it avoids UV filters like oxybenzone and octinoxate that damage coral reefs. Both brands demonstrate environmental consciousness while maintaining effective protection.

Price, size & availability

Value proposition varies significantly between these products. USA pricing ranges $13-$17 for Neutrogena Ultra Sheer, while Indie Lee retails at $42 from Amazon.

Size comparison reveals another disparity. Indie Lee provides 100ml for $42, while the competing brand's smaller 1.4-oz bottle requires more frequent repurchasing. Cost-per-ounce calculations still favor the SPF 70 formula significantly.

Availability differs markedly. The Ultra Sheer product enjoys widespread distribution through Target, Walgreens, CVS, Amazon, Ulta, and Walmart. EU availability includes €12-€16 pricing, though with more limited retail presence. Indie Lee's distribution remains primarily through specialty retailers and online channels.

Why mineral sunscreens are surging in 2025

The mineral sunscreen revolution reflects broader consumer priorities. The global mineral sunscreen market size is expected to reach USD 8.85 billion by 2030, growing at a CAGR of 13.5% from 2025 to 2030.

This market segment, estimated at $2.5 billion in 2025, is projected to exhibit a Compound Annual Growth Rate of 7% from 2025 to 2033. Key players drive innovation while expanding product lines to meet growing demand.

The market projects $362.8 million in 2025 with 6.8% CAGR through 2033. This growth stems from increased UV awareness and outdoor activity popularity, positioning both reviewed products within a rapidly expanding category.

Final verdict: Ultra Sheer takes the crown

After comprehensive testing and analysis, Neutrogena Ultra Sheer emerges as the superior choice for makeup wearers. Non-comedogenic, hypoallergenic, vegan formula suited for sensitive skin and makeup layering delivers on its promises.

Gentle sunscreen formulated free from problematic ingredients provides peace of mind alongside protection. The lightweight texture, minimal white cast, and eight-hour hydration create an ideal makeup base that outperforms Indie Lee's heavier, cast-prone formula.

While Indie Lee offers moisturizing benefits and ethical credentials, its texture challenges and visible residue make it less suitable for makeup application. For those prioritizing seamless makeup integration with high SPF protection, Neutrogena Ultra Sheer represents the clear winner.

ReviewStarz recommends Neutrogena Ultra Sheer for anyone seeking reliable sun protection that enhances rather than compromises their makeup routine. The combination of superior texture, higher SPF, and significantly lower price point makes it the practical choice for daily wear.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which sunscreen performs best under makeup?

Neutrogena Ultra Sheer comes out on top for makeup wear. Its lightweight, quick-drying texture leaves minimal white cast and layers smoothly under foundation, with SPF 70 protection at a budget-friendly price. Indie Lee offers hydration but its heavier feel and visible cast make it less makeup-friendly.

Does Neutrogena Ultra Sheer pill or leave a white cast under foundation?

In testing, it dries quickly and significantly reduces pilling risk, creating a smooth base for makeup. The finish is sheer with minimal cast, especially compared to heavier mineral formulas. Note that it is water resistant for up to 80 minutes, so reapply as directed during extended wear.

Who is Indie Lee Mineral Sunscreen best for?

Its squalane, shea butter, and aloe make it a good fit for dry skin that needs extra moisture. However, the rich texture can be hard to spread and may leave a noticeable white cast, which can interfere with shade matching. It is less ideal for those seeking an invisible finish under makeup.

What are the SPF levels and active filters in each formula?

Neutrogena Ultra Sheer provides SPF 70 with a dual-mineral blend of titanium dioxide and zinc oxide, plus vitamin E. Indie Lee offers SPF 30 with 20% uncoated zinc oxide. The dual-filter approach and higher SPF in Neutrogena contribute to broader protection and better aesthetics in our tests.

How do price and availability compare?

Neutrogena typically retails for about $13–$17 and is widely available at major retailers and online, offering strong cost-per-ounce value even in a smaller 1.4-oz bottle. Indie Lee costs about $42 for 100 ml and is primarily sold online and through specialty stores. Overall value favors Neutrogena for daily wear.

What did ReviewStarz testing conclude and where can I read it?

Our side-by-side wear tests found Neutrogena Ultra Sheer delivers a smoother, less cast-prone base with higher SPF at a lower price. Read the full ReviewStarz comparison at https://reviewstarz.com/neutrogena-ultra-sheer-vs-indie-lee-mineral-sunscreen-—-which-works-better-under-makeup? for detailed results and recommendations.